The Vietnam War was raging and diplomats in Paris spent weeks arguing over the shape of a table.
Four delegations would be present: the United States, South Vietnam, North Vietnam, and the National Liberation Front. But would they meet as four parties or two opposing sides? South Vietnam refused to recognise the Front as an equal negotiating partner. Giving each delegation a separate side of the table could suggest that all four had equal status. The furniture threatened to answer a question the diplomats could not agree on.
The eventual arrangement used an unmarked round table, with two separate rectangular tables for secretaries. The layout allowed the Americans and South Vietnamese to describe two opposing sides, while their opponents could describe four separate parties.
They could agree where to sit without agreeing what sitting there meant.
The negotiators had designed a way forward.
The Design Council defines design as “what happens when people use creativity to solve problems”. Those problems might concern a table, a local bus service, or how a company operates.
A salary discussion shows how designing and negotiating can happen together. An employee asks for a raise, but the employer cannot increase pay.
In Getting to Yes, Roger Fisher and William Ury distinguish between positions and interests. A position is what someone asks for. An interest is the want, need, goal, or concern behind the request. Higher pay is a position; having enough money to cover living costs is an interest.
Suppose commuting costs explain the employee’s request. Where the job allows, two days working from home could reduce travel costs. The employee has more money left over, while the employer gains a way to retain a valued colleague without raising wages.
Discussing salary alone means dividing a fixed pie—every extra pound for the employee costs the employer another pound. By broadening the discussion to include where the employee works, both sides have another way to meet their needs. Negotiators call this “expanding the pie”.
The employee and employer have changed how the job could work to meet their different needs. Their negotiation has produced a new design.
But working from home changes how the employee works with managers and colleagues. The team must decide how much freedom the employee has to make decisions, how progress will be assessed, and how responsibilities will be shared. These are choices about organisational design, which concerns who does what, who has authority, and how people work together.
Managers may want close oversight, employees may want independence, and colleagues may want a fair share of the workload. Developing a workable design therefore requires negotiation about how those different needs should be balanced.
Engineers face the same challenge. Louis Bucciarelli’s research shows how engineers negotiate competing priorities such as safety, performance, cost, and maintenance. Technical analysis helps compare the options, but people must agree which trade-offs are acceptable. Choosing the “best” design therefore means negotiating what “best” should mean.
People must also decide where to draw the boundary of the problem. Removing stops can make a bus journey faster but leave passengers walking further. Only counting time aboard the bus could favour fewer stops; counting the whole journey from home could favour a different route. Drawing that boundary already means deciding whose interests count.
Negotiation and design therefore involve the same connected decisions: understanding people’s interests, inventing ways to meet those interests, and agreeing which trade-offs are acceptable. Negotiators design new possibilities. Designers negotiate what those possibilities must achieve and whose needs they must serve.
Crucially, agreement can still leave out people who bear the consequences. A solution that satisfies everyone present may leave someone absent paying the price.
The Paris table did not end the war. The diplomats negotiated a design that allowed further negotiation. Four delegations could sit down while two incompatible accounts of their presence remained.
That was enough to begin.